Referee's Report Form                                                   ISSN  0974 –  3340  

SUTRA: Referee's Report Form

You have been sent, with a request for a referee's report, an article (/paper/classroom notes/survey) which has been submitted for publication by the TMRF. Please return your report by e-mail using following form. Please note that the article and its contents should be treated as confidential. 

Reference number & title of article:

Author(s) names:

Your name:

Your e-mail address:

Date of completion of report:


1.  How strong is the case for publication of the article?

Delete all but one of the following.
(a) non-existent
(b) weak
(c) reasonable
(d) good
(e) strong
(f) outstanding

2.  If the article has serious defects, how strong would the case be if a successful revision were carried out?

Delete all but one of the following.
(a) non-existent
(b) weak
(c) reasonable
(d) good
(e) strong
(f) outstanding
(g) question not applicable

3. GENERAL COMMENTS
Please include your review of the article here. This part of the report may be passed on to the author(s) and should include any criticism that might help the author to improve the article.







4. SPECIFIC CORRECTIONS
We don't ask our referees to look for typos, but any corrections that you add here will be welcome and passed on to the authors





5. CONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS
Please include your opinion of the quality of the article here and specify which of changes above that you recommended to the author would be essential for the article to reach the standard appropriate for the Sutra Journal. These remarks will only be passed on to the Editorial Adviser.






On completion, please send this report to director@tmrfindia.org.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

NOTE: The Editorial Board is anxious to reach decisions as quickly as possible. So, please acknowledge receipt of the article and this form by e-mail to  director@tmrfindia.org and let us know your estimate of when you will return the report to the TMRF Office (e-mail: director @ tmrfindia . org). 

Read Submission Guidelines before sending the manuscript to Sutra »

Sutra welcomes submissions from within and without the international mathematical community. Articles may feature new results, surveys of recent work in a particular field, profiles of mathematicians past or present, historical notes and so on...