ISSN 0972-9038                          Referee Report Format

 

Referee Report ( You may download Doc file)

Paper Id: _______________

 

Referee's Name:___________________________________________

 

Paper Title: ______________________________________________

 

1. Type of paper:  (Choose the appropriate choice.)

 

Research results  

Survey  

 Tutorial  

 Speculative 

 

2. Category in which the paper best fits in: (Choose the appropriate choice.)

 

Algebraic theory of computing and Formal systems

Algorithm and system implementation issues

Approximation and Randomized algorithms

Symbolic computation 

Operating systems

Scheduling

Software engineering

Picture processing

Classical numerical analysis

Numerical software

Numerical statistics

Artificial Intelligence

Automata, Learning theory  and Formal languages

Automated deduction

Combinatorics and Graph theory

Complexity theory

Computational biology and bioinformatics

Cryptography

Database theory

Data structures

Design and analysis of algorithms

DNA computing

 Computer security

High-performance computing

Logic in computer science

Quantum computing

 Internet computing

Parallel and distributed computing

Wireless networks and mobile computing

Programming Languages and Paradigms


3. Please rate the paper on the following features. (Choose the appropriate choice.)

Item 

Poor 

Unattractive 

Acceptable 

Good 

Excellent 

Potential interest to CS community 

 

 

 

 

 

Significance of the main idea(s) 

 

 

 

 

 

Originality of the work 

 

 

 

 

 

Technical quality of the paper 

 

 

 

 

 

Awareness of related work

 

 

 

 

 

Clarity of presentation 

 

 

 

 

 

 
4. How confident are you in your rating of this paper? Circle the relevant option.
 

Very  

Adequate   

Unsure

 

5. Comments (if any) for the Editor's use:
   

6. Comments to be communicated to the author. If require please use  on a separate sheet (the referee's identity will not be disclosed to the authors). If you have recommended the paper for rejection then please try to explain why you did so, in a constructive manner.
   

 

7. Overall Evaluation for consideration as a regular paper (Please tick the appropriate choice):
 

Definite Accept  

Marginal Accept  

Likely Reject  

Definite Reject 

 

 ________________________
Referee's Signature

Read Submission Guidelines before sending the manuscript to IJCSA »

Journal Indices: The IJCSA is indexed in INSPEC, Digital Bibliography & Library Project (DBLP), Elektronische Zeitschriftenbibliothek, Directory of Open Access Journals in CS (DOAJ) and WorldCat: Computer Literature Index.