IJCSA Referee Form

Referee Report

Paper Id: _______________

Referee's Name:___________________________________________

Paper Title: ______________________________________________

1. Type of paper: (Choose the appropriate choice.)

Research results

Survey

Tutorial

Speculative

2. Category in which the paper best fits in: (Choose the appropriate choice.)

         a. Machine intelligence with specific emphasis on:
            - expert, agents, diagnostic and decision supporting systems;
            - data and web mining;
            - neural networks, fuzzy systems, rough set theory, chaos theory and evolutionary algorithms;
            - reasoning, knowledge extraction and knowledge management.
        b. Applications of computer science in modeling.
        c. Visualization and multimedia.
        d. Data and information systems.
        e. Internet and distributed computer systems.
        f. Semantic Web technologies.
        g. Other (Specify ____________________________________________ )

3. Please rate the paper on the following features. (Choose the appropriate choice.)

Item	Poor	Unattractive	Acceptable	Good	Excellent
Potential interest to CS community
Significance of the main idea(s)
Originality of the work
Technical quality of the paper
Awareness of related work
Clarity of presentation

4. How confident are you in your rating of this paper? Circle the relevant option.

Very

Adequate

Unsure

5. Comments (if any) for the Editor's use:

6. Comments to be communicated to the author. If require please use on a separate sheet (the referee's identity will not be disclosed to the authors). If you have recommended the paper for rejection then please try to explain why you did so, in a constructive manner.

7. Overall Evaluation for consideration as a regular paper (Please tick the appropriate choice):

Definite Accept

Marginal Accept

Likely Reject

Definite Reject

________________________
Referee's Signature