Referee Form

Technomathematics Research Foundation 

e-Book Series Referee Form (TXT File)


Please return your report by e-mail using this form. Please note that the report  and its contents should be treated as confidential.

Reference number or title of manuscript:

Your name:

Your e-mail address:

Date of completion of report:


1.  How strong is the case for publication of the paper?

Delete all but one of the following.
(a) non-existent
(b) weak
(c) reasonable
(d) good
(e) strong
(f) outstanding

2.  If the paper has serious defects, how strong would the case be if a successful revision were carried out?

Delete all but one of the following.
(a) non-existent
(b) weak
(c) reasonable
(d) good
(e) strong
(f) outstanding

3. GENERAL COMMENTS
Please include your review of the manuscript here. This part of the report may be passed on to the author(s) and should include any criticism that might help the author to improve the paper.




4. SPECIFIC CORRECTIONS
We don't ask our referees to look for typos, but any corrections that you add here will be welcome and passed on to the authors



5. COMMENTS FOR EDITORS
Please include your opinion of the quality of the manuscript here and specify which of the changes above that you recommended to the author would be essential for the manuscript to reach the standard appropriate for the e-Book Series volume.
These remarks will only be passed on to the Editorial Adviser or the Editors of the series.



On completion, please send this report to tmrfseries@gmail.com


Series Indices: